nu, it's almost xmas, so who cares?
it's getting to be that time of year again, folks. it's not even thanksgiving and the xmas commercials have already hit the tv. not a problem in my world--not yet, anyway. sure i can stomach the images of the ubiquitous green bean casserole, the images of trees being lit up all over the the tv, and the random selections of decorations set up all over the stores. not oppressive, not offensive.
i'm even past the point of being annoyed about receiving the yearly invitation to xmas dinner at the home of one of our relatives. (and no, i don't know if we're going yet, but if we do, i'm sure we'll be stopping at mendy's first....) this actually used to kill me, back in college, having to sit through dinner with the family, while a great big (and beautiful) tree beckoned us with promises of gifts wrapped in chanukah paper (my mom was annoyed that our gifts would be wrapped in xmas paper, go mom....), candy canes, and other random goodies awaited the moment that all would gather together and open everything. of course, there was the electric menorah in the window, a few scattered dreidles, and some chocolate gelt on the coffee table so the jewish side wouldn't feel "left out." these small tokens probably found themselves in a pretty confusing environment, as did i, the girl who for some reason owned a stocking as a little kid and remembers opening a few small gifts one xmas morning in her (jewish) parents' house. among the dreidles and gelt was also a plate of latkes, apple sauce and sour cream. another plate held small sausage links that had been pinned to the turkey. on a small board sat a few different types of cheese, crackers and a cutting knife. year after year it was always the same, although the latkes didn't come until much later, possibly when i hit those college years--the time of self-exploration, you know, when you realize that your jewish heritage is more than just a matzah ball and some jarred borscht, it is also a latke, kugel and schav.
dinner was always a meal of which (hopefully) everyone could partake: turkey, sausage stuffing (which then renders even the most kosher of kosher turkeys treyfe...), macaroni and cheese (are those real bits of bacon in there?), possibly a lasagna with meat, a salad, candied yams, tasteless vegetables of some random sort--well, you get the idea. lots of things a kosher gal couldn't eat. but i wasn't offended. i only became offended when people other than the hosts of the meal made a big deal out of why i wasn't eating the food. it was never my intention to draw attention to my eating or lack thereof, but people who should have known better would make comments until sooner or later, the whole table was aware of my eating situation.
after the meal, the gifts, the dessert, and the goodbyes, my folks would then pack us into the car and we'd drive off to ozone park and howard beach where we'd drive around looking at the xmas lights. i used to wonder why we didn't drive around looking at menorahs....
but now i'm an adult and i don't feel threatened by xmas, or by other people's observance of the holiday, even in my own (strange) family. when i walk into department stores and see chanukah displays, i actually feel kind of like, "well what'd they go and do that for?" so yes, married with kids, a dog, and an impending move to israel, xmas is really no longer a big deal. if we go this year to our random relative, it'll be like any other family dinner--we won't eat what's served, we'll be insulted by the extreme leftist politics being spewed at us, and someone will criticize us for something we did, didn't do, thought about, or read in passing. just like any other day.
but, that's not the reason for this post.
as i said before, i don't feel that my jewishness is at all threatened by others' holiday celebrations. during ramadan, i don't feel the need to fast because i might miss out on something the muslims are doing. during easter, i don't paint eggs (although, i seem to remember doing that at one point when i was a kid, hmm...). i don't wipe black schmutz on my head on ash wednesday to be like the catholics. and no, i certainly don't set up a "chanukah bush" so that my kids won't feel like they're "missing out" on xmas.
so why, oh why then, does the non-odox synagogue out here, feel the need to host a holiday party (and that's what it's being touted as) on sunday night, december 24th? now, that could make sense if that day also coincided with chanukah, in which case, the party would be called a chanukah party. but, december 24th this year is actually after chanukah is over. it is also xmas eve. and of course, there is no reason why jews cannot party on xmas eve, actually we should, since these days we don't have to hide in our chicken coops hoping that there won't be a pogrom. but seriously, if a jewish party is being held on xmas eve, which is not also a jewish holiday (it's not even rosh chodesh(the new month)) then should it really be deemed a "holiday" party? whose holiday is being celebrated? and you can't tell me that during chanukah, a holiday of eight nights, there was absolutely no possible time to throw this party.
what i don't get is why there is a need to do anything at all. so, it's xmas. big deal. i'll do what i always do every night of the week. since it's a sunday, we'll probably spend it in monsey or at least either go out with the kids for dinner or lunch there, and then, we'll give the kids their baths, get them to bed, and veg out for a while before bed. possibly we'll have tea or hot chocolate, and i'll have to go back down to feed the dog or wash dishes. i might even do a load of laundry, or two, or ten. but i won't feel the need to acknowledge to myself or my children that it's xmas because it won't be a big deal to me. if we go to my relative's house the following day, i'll just explain that we're going to be with the family and that so and so has a tree to celebrate her holiday, just as we have a menorah to celebrate ours, or shabbos candles or a havdalah set, or a sukkah or whatever. and that'll be that and it's no big deal.
i mean, seriously folks, when was the last time you saw christians erecting a shack to eat in around sukkot because they felt bad that they didn't have one too? or the muslims wearing tennis sneakers with their suits on yom kippur because they felt left out?
enough of this, it's not even thanksgiving.
enjoy your turkey. or whatever you do this time of year.






12 Comments:
I think there was a time when we were younger ... people like us ... that our parent's succumbed to our lack of understanding about the whole Xmas versus Hanukkah thing.
One year, we had a tree too. Am I proud of it? Not particularly, but I'm not ashamed of it either. It just sort of 'was.'
I suppose I could never lambast a Jew who has a tree, having had one myself, and we could just hope for the best ... that one day, they will be able to differentiate between the beauty of their heritage, and the over-commercialization [and beauty] of someone else's.
Let's just be happy that we no longer do those things. Because every time a Jew eats bacon, to me at least, it's as thought the Holy Beis Hamikdash is being desecrated all over again.
i hope this didn't come off like i'm lambasting jews with trees. i'm just saying that i don't feel the need to say/do anything regarding xmas because it's not a big deal unless people turn it into one. i don't see why some jews are concerned so much with it. a better way to counter xmas would be to celebrate jewish holidays, shabbos, etc, and raise children with awareness that their own heritage and religion is filled with so many amazing, wonderful holidays and traditions.
Chanukah displays in the stores used to make me fume too. I've had heated discussions with other hebrew school teachers about why I don't get this, and they don't get my point either. Guess it's good I'm here. :)
Last December my 5 year old (then 4 1/2) declared on his own that we needed to move to israel because there was just too much christmas in florida. The displays and stuff are just overwhelming and he felt it as a young kid....we chose then to start the aliyah discussions with him!
anyway, i'm babbling....and tell me again, they PIN THE SAUSAGE to the turkey? I've got a funny picture in my head!
there's a commerical on cbs newsradio by that jewish group (the american jewish committee, i think) that says thanksgiving originated from sukkot :)
one of the classics this year was when i managed to completely shelter my kids from anything and everything halloween. needless to say, many of the people i know thought this to be a bit extreme, you know, denying my kids the fun of trick-or-treating and dressing up....
at any rate, emah, what a more perfect time to address aliyah!
and as for pinning the sausage, i think they use either wooden toothpicks or small metal single serve kebab sticks (like hors d'ouevre size) to attach (breakfast link size) sausages to the outside of the turkey. then, when they baste it, the fat from the sausage gets into the meat. whatever happened to just using some nice herbs and white wine?
disclaimer: the above was just an explanation of how to pin sausages to a turkey. unless the turkey and sausages are both kosher, this is not a kosher preparation. boys and girls, please do not try this at home....
oh, and i also heard that about thanksgiving, very cool, eh?
Maybe the Native Americans were really jewish too? I mean, many of them had peyot, they just braided them instead of curling....hee hee not exactly modest dressers though, huH ? but those pilgrims, now those were some frum dressers! covered their hair and all!
I think you're onto something phish! by the way, still waiting for a new post from you? nu?
:)
emah s is that peyot or peyote??
mean, seriously folks, when was the last time you saw christians erecting a shack to eat
I don't think that's an argument at all as we are a minority whose customs are not discussed all over the news.
christmas an the ramdan don't interest me at all yet somehow I always now when they occur, each year.
I think the answer is that most of the world is celebrating xmas, even in Israel.
We do not want to feel lonely and therefore we try to organize something.
We won't call it a holiday party (since it's not one) but the true reason is that we don't want to be the only one who just watch (xmas programs, what else is on?) Tv that night.
Ideally Jews should work on that night, we could make a fortune as rates are tripled and we wouldn't care, it'd be like every other evening!
I always work on Xmas
i was in israel for winter break about 4 years ago. i called my father and he told me he was home. i asked if he was felling ok, why was he not at work. he reminded me he was off because of christmas (or was it New Years, i forget). i thought it was great that being in israel and not bombarded with the holiday environment i had completely forgotten about christmas altogether.
saldy, i read an article last year (in jpost?) that some israelis are starting to celebrate christmas as a day of gift-giving.
Although Christians have premepted the season to make it a Christian celebration the holiday predates the Christians by centuries. The tree and the yule log are pagan symbols. I enjoy the holiday season..but not because it is a Christian or any other religious holiday..I just like the idea of holiday and figure that every day should be a holiday.
Post a Comment
<< Home